1st Round Review
The first round of the draft was crazy with picks changing hands early and often. Some teams took steps to build for the future. Others took players to help their playoff push. Others filled gaping holes. There were not a lot of “are you kidding me” moments in the 1st round. Here are some thoughts on the round.
1) Jason Heyward-Napa. This pick was a no-brainer. Talent like Heyward comes along once every 10 years or so and Napa wasted little time selecting the hulking RF. The man can run, field, hit with power, and take a walk. Heyward should be a star for a decade. Injuries are the only thing that can stop this kid. Now the question is if Napa will hold onto him or feed his draft addiction. This player should be signed to a long term deal ASAP.
2) Buster Posey-Brighton. Brighton spent a majority of the off season looking to upgrade at catcher. After much posturing, Brighton acquired the #2 pick and was thrilled to bring “Buster” into the fold. He provides the defense and arm that management covets, but also hits well. Barring injury, Brighton should be set at catcher for the foreseeable future.
3) Stephen Strasburg-Halifax. Halifax management traded shutdown lefty Kuo to move up one spot to assure that Strasburg was available. Until his injury, Strasburg was assured to be a top 2 pick. Halifax is in rebuild mode and can wait for Strasburg. Word has it that he is progressing ahead of schedule. If so, Halifax should have his ace. Strasburg, Morrow, Sale, Carrasco, and Anderson could be an imposing rotation in a couple years.
4) Carlos Santana-Napa. After trading away the #2 pick and any shot at Posey, Napa picked another high ceiling backstop in Santana. Many are calling him V-Mart part 2. Santana has adequate power and an uncanny ability to get on base. He will never be a gold glove candidate, but he is in the lineup for his bat. The only question is how well he comes back from his knee injury. He seems to be fine. With Heyward and Santana, Napa has two all-star caliber players to build upon.
5) Mike Stanton-Aberdeen. Stanton is pure power and Aberdeen was happy to put him on the draft board. There is little doubt that Stanton can and will put up 40 HR’s sometime in the not-to-distant future. On top of that, he is an excellent defender. On the flipside, like most power hitters, he strikes out at a high rate and needs to learn to take more pitches. If he can develop patience, he could be a right handed Adam Dunn with defense.
6) Pedro Alvarez-Old Bridge. Old Bridge was in dire need of adding power to its lineup. Alvarez provides that at a tough position. While not an ace with the glove, he flashed great power in his rookie season. There has been chatter of a move to 1B in the future for Alvarez, but Old Bridge will not worry about that now. Like most young sluggers, he strikes out often and walks infrequently. Old Bridge can live with those imperfections as long as the power is there and the defense at least stays the same.
7) Colby Lewis-Oregon. Lewis is probably the best SP for the season available. Lewis is hardly a young, can’t miss prospect. He has bounced around the minors and Japan. With that said, Oregon has a need for a good SP and Lewis fits the bill. He had an outstanding season and maybe Nolan Ryan’s influence has rubbed off. A repeat is unlikely, but he should remain a useful starting pitcher.
8) Jeremy Hellickson-Aberdeen. Aberdeen’s second 1st round pick came in handy as he selected hot pitching prospect Hellickson. He showed well in his brief time with Tampa last season and with the trade of Garza, will almost be assured of a prominent role this year. While he will be of little use to Aberdeen this season, he is expected to be a top tier starter for the Iron Birds for years to come.
9) Daniel Hudson-Nassau. Nassau traded out of his original #2 slot with the #9 pick being returned. Steve selected Daniel Hudson. While Hudson does not project to be an ace, he should develop into a solid #2/3 which will suit Nassau just fine. While he has limited innings this year, Nassau is looking towards the future and Hudson should be a big part of it. I had Castro going to Nassau and that may have been the better pick, but I can’t imagine Steve will regret having a solid pitcher in the middle of his rotation for awhile.
10) Austin Jackson-Helena. Gold glove caliber centerfielders with some speed don’t grow on trees, so Helena management scooped up the Tiger OF with the 10th pick. Jackson roams the spacious CF of Comerica Park with grace and will provide consistent 1-2 ratings in CF for years. Rumor has it that Jim Leyland will allow him to run more often this year which bodes well for Helena. On the flipside, 170 strikeouts for a guy who hit 4 homers is cause for concern. He must learn to make better contact and take a few more walks. Jackson proved he has merit in year 1. A solid pick at #10.
11) Starlin Castro-Halifax. Castro surprisingly fell to #11 and although Halifax has veteran Alex Gonzalez at SS, he was happy to select the young Cub SS. Castro’s bat was excellent and immediately puts him into the upper echelon of SS’s in the league. While Castro has decent range, he makes careless errors and that will have to improve. He does not have great speed or power. He manages to find the gaps when he hits the ball. Sabermetric geeks will argue that will decline. Others pundits think Castro is legit.
12) Ike Davis-Halifax. Acquired from Bartonville in the John Danks deal, Ike Davis fills a glaring need at 1B. Son of former closer Ron Davis, Ike showed the makings of an above average 1B. He flashed a solid glove, solid power, and the ability to get on base. He will never be a prominent slugger along the lines of Pujols, Votto, or Cabrera. However, he should be a consistent .275/20/80 type 1B with a good glove. Mark Grace??? I am sure Halifax will be happy with that.
13) Madison Bumgarner-London. London has built its team around pitching and this years pick follow the pattern. The lefty from SF turned in a solid performance and will provide some value this season. While he may not have “ace” potential like Strasburg or Hellickson, he projects to be a fine #2/3 type. Pitching in SF will help and is a good value now and for the future. London hopes to battle for the playoffs so having potential AND 111 useful innings is invaluable.
14) Dominic Brown-Bowling Green. With a rapidly aging OF, Bowling Green opted against immediate help to go with hot prospect Dominic Brown. The Phills allowed Jason Werth to walk and all but handed the starting job to Brown. He has all the tools to be a star. Unfortunately, a broken hand in spring training will put those plans on hold.
15) Neil Walker-Oahu. Management had coveted local boy Pedro Alvarez, but he was selected by Old Bridge. Jim decided to stay local and grab the lone 2B prospect worthy of a 1st rd pick. With this move, Martin Prado slides over to 3B, and portly Pablo Sandoval sits on the pine. Oahu could have used some help in his rotation and grabbed Chacin, Kennedy, or Garcia. Walker may not have the pedigree to be a star, but the converted catcher gets on base and is a switch hitter. He hits righties and lefties well and is capable with the glove.
16) Jamie Garcia-Helena. Garcia is a solid value at #16. Many had him going sooner and Helena is happy that he didn’t. With his trades of pitchers Matt Garza, Yovani Gallardo, and Fausto Carmona, Helena needed to fill those slots and Garcia does just that.
He likely will never win 20 games or be “the man” for the Cards, he provides current and some future value for the Handbaskets.
17) Ian Kennedy-Aberdeen. Aberdeen is back and this time selects a pitcher to help him in the here and now. Kennedy showed the promise that made him a Yankee prospect. Now out of the bright lights, he excelled in Arizona. No one will claim that Kennedy will be a top tier starter, but he is still young and should shape nicely into a good #3 for a good club. With Hellickson in the mix, Aberdeen likely has his ace of the future. With limited options remaining at SP, it was not a bad pickup. Some may say that Chacin has more upside, but Kennedy is probably the safer pick.
18) Jhoulys Chacin-Helena. Helena is also a very busy team in this first round. As mentioned in the Garcia breakdown, Chacin will help replace some of the departed starter innings. Chacin showed that he belonged last year and held an impressive K rate. On the flip side, he also showed that he needs to work on his control and pitching in Coors is never an enticing thought. However, getting Chacin at #18 is a bargain. With Chacin, Garcia, Volquez, and Nolasco, Helena has some promising arms for the future. Add them to Zito, Peavy, and Dickey, they will have enough arms to put together a respectable starting 5.
19) Drew Storen-London. London sticks to his dedication to pitching by taking the young Storen. This may have been a bit of a reach for him, but London does not have a young or lights out closer. Kerry Wood and Brandon League are not what playoffs are built upon. There were some very good RP cards this year, and veteran closer Billy Wagner was available, but London goes with Storen who can close now and has the pedigree to be an upper echelon closer for years. While it was a reach, it was a good pick for some value now and in the future.
20) Jonny Venters-Reno. Reno spent the off season putting itself in a position to make a run at a divisional title. They have the bats, but the bullpen outside of Rivera was a glaring weakness. Enter Jonny V. He was the premier lefty available and will also get an opportunity to close for Atlanta giving him a shot at increased value for the future. His card is very impressive and logged a lot of innings making him extremely valuable bridging the gap to Rivera. On the flipside, he has never shown much of a track history in the minors and relief pitchers are the most volatile performers year to year. That aside, Venters will prove invaluable to Reno’s playoff aspirations and anything he gets next year and beyond is a bonus.
Best Picks-
1) Buster Posey-Brighton. OK…..maybe I am a little biased, but after spending all off season trying to fix my glaring weak spot, I was giddy to land Posey. Santana would have been nice, but Posey helps my playoff goals with his bat, glove, and arm.
2) Jason Heyward-Napa. Having the #1 pick, the pressure is one to pick a can’t miss player. Heyward is about as can’t miss as it gets. The trade addicted Napa probably would even hang onto Heyward. The only thing that can derail the star in the making is the injury bug.
3) Starlin Castro-Halifax. I had Castro going as early as #5. I think the value at #11 is great. Personally, I am not as enamored as many others with Castro. However, I don’t doubt that he will be a solid SS for years. If he can improve his defense and keep the offense up, he could be a top 5 guy for awhile.
Questionable picks of the round-
1) Drew Storen-London. Again, not a bad pick and I understand the thought behind selecting Storen. He has good upside and London needs to address his closer situation. I believe that he could have been had in the 2nd, but you never know who goes when. A reach, but an understandable one.
2) Daniel Hudson-Nassau. Similar to Storen, not a bad pick at all. However, with Ramon Santiago and Cesar Izturis as his shortstops, Starlin Castro may have been the way to go. Of course you can never have too much pitching so it isn’t as if Nassau wasted the pick.
3) Colby Lewis-Oregon. I do not question that Lewis is good. Oregon is riding a fine line between rebuild and trying for playoffs. If rebuilding, Castro or Hellickson may have made more sense. It looks as if Oregon wants to compete now. With that said, SP was a need and Lewis was best SP for current value.
-- Mark Moilanen